Why People Play the Lottery and Why State Governments Have a Hard Time Abandoning Them
The practice of making decisions or determining fates by lot dates back centuries. The Old Testament tells Moses to take a census of Israel and divide its land by lottery, and Roman emperors held lotteries as entertainment during Saturnalian feasts. In modern times, states have introduced lotteries to raise money for a wide range of social and public policy purposes, including schools, roads, hospitals, and disaster relief. Lottery proceeds have also been seen as a way to avoid raising taxes or cutting essential services. Yet despite the fact that lotteries have been a proven revenue source for state governments and have generally enjoyed broad public approval, they remain controversial.
The debate about lotteries has focused primarily on whether or not they promote gambling addiction and the alleged regressive impact on poorer households. But there are other underlying issues that need to be addressed if we are to understand the reason why people play, and why state governments have a hard time abandoning them.
In the beginning, state governments viewed lotteries as a nice little bit of income that would enable them to expand their offerings without increasing taxes on middle-class and working-class citizens. In the wake of World War II, this arrangement allowed states to invest in a much more expansive array of services without significantly burdening their working-class populations. In the immediate post-war period, it seemed like this arrangement could last indefinitely, a notion that was perhaps fueled by the euphoria of victory and the expectation that the new prosperity was bound to continue to grow.
But now that the lottery industry has matured, the focus has moved from its overall desirability to more specific problems and challenges, such as the reliance on advertising and the difficulty of managing compulsive gambling. The fact that most state lotteries have evolved into a multi-faceted business has further complicated these concerns, as the management of each component of the business has become more independent and self-contained. As a result, it is more difficult to maintain a consistent public-policy approach.
When it comes to winning the lottery, most players have some sort of quote-unquote system that they think increases their chances of success. They may buy tickets in certain stores or at particular times, pick numbers that are their birthdays or home addresses, or look for a specific pattern that might signal a win. But the reality is that winning the lottery is random. Even if you have a system, it will only increase your chance of winning by one in 100,000.
The real secret to winning the lottery is not a system, it’s a promise. A promise to share your winnings, or at least most of them, with others. This is the only thing that really increases your odds of winning. It is this promise that makes the lottery so enduringly popular in an age of declining social mobility and limited economic security. People know that they are unlikely to win, but they still hope that they will, and they keep playing because it makes them feel good about themselves.